Ducted Evaporative Cooling vs Ducted Air Conditioning
Quick Verdict
Ducted evaporative costs 70-80% less to run and works excellently in dry climates (Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne, inland areas). Ducted AC works in all climates and offers precise control. In suitable climates, evaporative saves $400-$800/year in running costs.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Ducted Evaporative Cooling | Ducted Air Conditioning |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront Cost | $3,500-$7,000 installed | $8,000-$20,000 installed |
| Running Cost | $0.10-$0.20/hour | $2.00-$3.50/hour |
| Cooling Power | Whole-home cooling in dry conditions | Whole-home precise cooling |
| Best Climate | Hot-dry, mild-temperate (humidity <50%) | All climates |
| DIY Install? | No | No |
Ducted Evaporative Cooling
Central evaporative unit on roof with ducts to each room. Requires windows/doors open.
Pros
- 70-80% cheaper running costs than ducted AC
- Fresh air circulation (not recirculated)
- Lower environmental impact
- Simpler maintenance (pads, pump)
- Works brilliantly in dry heat
Cons
- Ineffective in humid conditions
- Cannot cool to exact temperature
- Uses 15-25L water per hour
- Requires windows/doors cracked open
- Pads need annual replacement
Ducted Air Conditioning
Central refrigerative system with ducts to each room. Works with house sealed.
Pros
- Works in any climate or humidity
- Precise temperature control
- Also heats in winter (reverse cycle)
- Dehumidifies the air
- Zoning for room-by-room control
Cons
- Much higher running costs
- Higher upfront cost
- Complex maintenance requirements
- Recirculated air can feel stuffy
- If system fails, whole house affected
Climate Zone Guide
Hot-Dry Climates (WA, SA, Inland)
Ducted evaporative is the clear winner in Perth, Adelaide, and inland areas. It's half the upfront cost and runs for a fraction of the price. Many families run it all day long affordably.
Hot-Humid Climates (QLD, NT)
Ducted AC is essential in Brisbane, Darwin, and coastal Queensland. Evaporative cooling simply won't work when humidity exceeds 60%. Budget for higher running costs.
Temperate Climates (VIC, NSW, ACT)
Melbourne is ideal for evaporative - low humidity most days, with only occasional humid periods. Many homes have evaporative as primary with a split system backup for humid days.
Cost Analysis
Over summer (120 days, 8 hours/day), ducted evaporative costs $100-$200 to run. Ducted AC costs $1,920-$3,360. Annual savings with evaporative: $1,700-$3,200. Even accounting for the occasional humid day requiring alternative cooling, evaporative saves $1,500-$2,500/year in suitable climates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I have both ducted evaporative and ducted AC?
It's uncommon due to the cost of two ducted systems. A more practical approach is ducted evaporative for whole-home cooling plus one or two split systems for humid days or bedrooms. This gives you efficient cooling 90% of the time with reliable backup.
Which has better resale value?
Ducted AC typically adds more to resale value as it appeals to buyers from all climate backgrounds. However, in dry climate areas (Perth, Adelaide), well-maintained ducted evaporative is valued by local buyers who understand the running cost savings.
What maintenance is required?
Evaporative: Annual pad replacement ($100-$200), pump check, clean water tank. Takes 1-2 hours DIY. Ducted AC: Annual professional service ($150-$300), filter cleaning quarterly, refrigerant check. Both last 15-20 years with proper maintenance.
Get a Personalized Recommendation
Not sure which is best for your home? Answer a few questions and get tailored advice based on your climate, home type, and budget.
Get My Free Plan